This question was closed without grading. Reason: Answer found elsewhere
Apr 22, 2020 05:07
4 yrs ago
53 viewers *
German term

echter und unechter Solidarität

German to English Law/Patents Law (general) It's about joint liability in car crashes involving multiple cars (Massenkarambolage)
For more context: Ganz offensichtlich steht und fällt die Solidarität mit der Kausalität. Ob dem wirklich so ist, soll im ersten Teil dieses Beitrags untersucht werden. Dabei sind namentlich die unterschiedlichen Formen des kausalen Zusammenwirkens näher zu beleuchten, die für die Zurechnung entscheidend sind. Untersucht werden soll auch die für überflüssig gehaltene Unterscheidung von echter und unechter Solidarität, für die hier - erneut7 und fast gegen die gesamte Literatur - eine Lanze gebrochen wird. Unter die Lupe genommen wird auch, was das Bundesgericht mit dem einheitlichen Schaden meint, der zwingend Solidarität zur Folge haben soll: "Liegt ein einheitlicher Schaden vor, der durch mehrere verursacht worden ist, auferlegt das Gesetz den Schädigern eine solidarische Haftung

Vielen Dank im Voraus!

Discussion

Haigo Salow (asker) Apr 24, 2020:
I apologize for not having responded to any of the contributions, but my computer crashed yesterday (first time ever) and I'm just getting back to work. I got the so-called Windows Blue Screen of Death.
Sebastian Witte Apr 22, 2020:
I fail to see why anyone would decide to put "joint" in brackets in their answer as it marks the very core of the legal concept concerned. Solidarität = solidarische Haftung. It is all there in that excerpt. Solidarische Haftung = gesamtschuldnerische Haftung.

Proposed translations

-1
2 hrs

real and spurious joint liability

Thanks this is a really cool question.

"The supposed superfluous distinction between actual and spurious joint liability is also to be examined."

This is about joint liability (solidarschuld, Solidarität) among those involved in joint liability mass car accident and whether their joint liability in terms of the legal case is real (actual) or just convenient or random (spurious).

See second reference below for example of "real" and "spurious" used together. :-)
Peer comment(s):

disagree AllegroTrans : 'random' and 'spurious' convey nothing concerning liability and I have never seen any legal text using either term; have you?
6 hrs
Something went wrong...
+1
5 hrs
German term (edited): (CH) echte und unechte Solidarität /Solidarhaftung/

primary and secondary, mulitple-headed joint and several liability

Solidarität: often Swiss for Solidarhaftung.

Query in US-Am. fed. state law: strict vs. 'non-strict' joint & several liability - pls. see the second wblink.

Unechte / multiple-cause: could include vicarious vs. direct liability of an employer for a van-driving employee who has caused a road accident.

First weblink: Es kann vorkommen, dass einzelne Schädiger einen persönlichen Herabsetzungsgrund (defens/ce entered in mitigation) geltend machen könnten, wobei dies im Falle der Solidarhaftung nicht so einfach ist. Eine Verjährungsunterbrechung ist nur bei echter Solidarität möglich. Im Zusammenspiel mit Versicherungen stellt sich zudem die Frage nach dem Quotenvorrecht. Schlussendlich wird noch die Frage aufgeworfen, wie die Solidarhaftung bei internationalen Verhältnissen aus Schweizer Sicht zu beurteilen sei.

see also, in a Swiss context, echte Solidarschulld vs. subsidiäre Haftung: Das vorliegende Urteil betrifft die Übertragung eines Mietverhältnisses (OR 263). Strittig war die Frage, ob Abs. 4 dieser Bestimmung eine echte Solidarschuld i.S.v. OR 143 ff. anordnet oder doch eine subsidiäre Haftung des übertragenden Mieters für den Fall, dass der erwerbende Mieter nicht leiste. https://swissblawg.ch/2014/07/4a5002013-echte-solidarhaftung...

Kausalität > rather than causality, means causation split in Anglo-Am. tort law into proximate and non-proximate or remote causation.-
Example sentence:

CH: echte Solidarität > Wenn mehrere Personen den Schaden gemeinsam verschuldet haben, so haften sie dem Geschädigten aufgrund der Solidarhaftung *solidarisch* (Art. 50 Abs. 1 OR).

CH: m Gegensatz zur echten Solidarität haften bei der unechten Solidarität mit der Solidarhaftung mehrere Personen *aus unterschiedlichen Rechtsgründen* (sog. *mehrtypische* unechte Solidarität).

Peer comment(s):

agree Chris Pr : "Joint and Several" (Solidarity): Swiss source: https://www1.unisg.ch/www/edis.nsf/vEDISByTitleEN/7293A6E83B...
15 hrs
Yes, thx, but the asker's problem could lie, for instance, with echte vs. unechte cf. the German variety of Gesamtschuld §§ 421, 422 & 426 BGB.
Something went wrong...
12 hrs

primary and secondary (joint) liability

My answer is yes, a simplification of Adrian's.

The article appears to be making the well-known point that in mutiple vehicle accidents, there is often a situation in which the injured party has a choice on who to sue, ranging from the driver who hit him/her, down to the driver who first caused the accident. The classis example is a bumper-to-bumper RTA involving several vehicles.

The law knows many other circumstances in which similar principles apply.

Secondary Liability: charging decisions on principals and ...
www.cps.gov.uk › legal-guidance › secondary-liability-...
4 Feb 2019 - Prior to R v Jogee, there were two main qualifications that limited the scope of secondary liability. D2 was not liable where: D1's act is “ ...

The Law Applicable to Secondary Liability in Intellectual ...
www.law.columbia.edu › files › microsites › kernochan
PDF
16 Oct 2013 - Addressing questions of choice of law in cases of secondary liability runs headlong into ... primary question of direct liability and a secondary question of whether a third party ... sons hosting a large bit-torrent tracker. Id. at 16.

Secondary liability - Wikipedia
en.wikipedia.org › wiki › Secondary_liability
In other words, courts, rather than Congress, have been the primary developers of theories and policies concerning secondary liability. Contents. 1 Early case law ...

Something went wrong...
+1
4 hrs

genuine and pseudo joint liability

Compare with this:
"42 Ibid., Article 68. In this article, an imitative form of joint liability that is derived from the concept “Unechte Solidaritat” in German law is imposed on the polluter and the third party. In this pseudo joint liability, the victim is entitled to choose either the polluter or the third party from whom to claim compensation for their pollution damage. The polluter has the right of recourse against the third party after having compensated the victims." https://imarest.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00908320.201...

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 14 hrs (2020-04-22 19:52:20 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

Whilst I agree that for translation purposes it is better to determine what would be used in the target culture (English-speaking common-law country) rather than fall into the common trap of "explaining what the German means", I must admit that in this case I happen to be more fascinated by the German angle than the best culture-appropriate solution.

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 15 hrs (2020-04-22 20:26:09 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

I initially figured it would be more fruitful to find something that ties in with the author's explanation of the solidarity principle than to find a more 'authoritative' term that may not fit so well with what the author tries to explain in that paragraph.

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 15 hrs (2020-04-22 20:37:28 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

Also see this source on how various law systems " deal with multiple debtors in contract.
...development of quasi-solidarity (unechte Solidarität)..." https://books.google.com/books?id=uR8C-vcwOEIC&pg=RA4-PA41&l...
Peer comment(s):

agree Rachel Goodwin : genuine and pseudo are the same words that also sprang to my mind
7 mins
Thanks, Rachel!
neutral AllegroTrans : Whilst your ref does indeed use the word "pseudo" to explain things, I cannot see it as an any way authoritative single adjective that is really viable here, it just sounds totally vague
7 hrs
This may not be the 'best' solution, but see my added note.
Something went wrong...
Term search
  • All of ProZ.com
  • Term search
  • Jobs
  • Forums
  • Multiple search