Apr 19 15:01
19 days ago
37 viewers *
French term

diabolisée ou enchantée

French to English Social Sciences Government / Politics ecological transition
This is from a text about the ecological transition and how it should be carried out fairly ("la transition juste").

I currently have this as "demonized or unfairly blamed", since other factors such as AI (mentioned elsewhere) are likely to have a bigger impact on society. So, "ne doit pas être enchantée" in the sense of "should not be presented as having bewitching powers".

However, I am concerned I might be missing something.

Any comments welcome.

Enfin, la transition ne doit pas être diabolisée ou enchantée au regard de ses effets, sur l’emploi, les
revenus, la cohésion sociale, la confiance dans les institutions politiques. La transition peut contribuer
significativement à la compétitivité, la souveraineté, la prospérité et la vitalité démocratique de la
France. Toutefois, d’autres processus géostratégiques, économiques, financiers, politiques,
technologiques, sanitaires mais aussi démographiques tels que la métropolisation et la désertification
des campagnes, ont pesé et pèsent toujours bien plus sur notre économie et notre société. La transition
n’est pas la cause déterminante des difficultés économiques et sociales que nous pouvons rencontrer et
doit être d’autant plus sanctuarisée que le contexte est difficile.

Discussion

Lisa Rosengard Apr 25:
Thank you, Mark!
Mark Nathan (asker) Apr 23:
Lisa Yes, I don't see why you shouldn't print it - it's in the public domain, and its purpose is to "nourrir le débat".
Lisa Rosengard Apr 23:
Daryo Daryo's reference is excellent. Should it be OK to print its 10 pages? I'd like a proper read in my own time.
Mark Nathan (asker) Apr 19:
Opposites I originally thought it was an opposite, so "glorified" or something similar, but then became doubtful having read more of the article, in which the idea that we should not blame the transition for broader problems is developed. Although perhaps Emmanuella's angéliser, could work as "or viewed with naive optimism".
Emmanuella Apr 19:
Vu qu'il s'agit d'antonymes, nous pourrions peut-être utiliser le terme 'angéliser'
https://www.lalanguefrancaise.com/dictionnaire/definition/an...
https://www.lemonde.fr/idees/article/2021/09/02/transition-e...
Are these not opposites? Since the effects of the "transition juste" listed beneath the two terms includes positives and negatives, I wonder if "enchantée" is used as an opposite to "diabolisée". I'm thinking of "demonized" and "glorified", although I admit that "enchantée" does seem a strange term to use here.

Proposed translations

+4
10 hrs
Selected

portrayed as diabolical or redemptory

be denigrated or lauded
be portrayed as diabolical or as a magical remedy
... as a poison or a cure
... as an afflication or a panacea

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 10 hrs (2024-04-20 01:04:37 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

Or quite simply "portrayed as all-bad or all-good".
Peer comment(s):

agree AllegroTrans : some good 'uns there // peidiwch â sôn amdano
14 hrs
Tak, spasibo, thanks, merci, ta, danke, gracias.
agree Nicole Acher : captures the meaning exactly
23 hrs
agree Julie Barber
1 day 7 hrs
neutral philgoddard : Why use three words, portrayed as diabolical, when you can use one, demonised?
1 day 12 hrs
Would you believe 'Paid by the SL word', you old devil, you?
agree SafeTex : I prefer "salvatory" to "redemption" but this is the best suggestion up IMHO
1 day 13 hrs
Something went wrong...
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer. Comment: "Thanks everybody"
+1
55 mins

doomed or idealized

Hello! This question is very interesting. I suggested “doomed” or something like “doomed from the start”, but I think “demonized” works perfectly.

I also understand your discomfort with “unfairly blamed”, which although it is also appropriate, ignores the part about the ecological transition not falling into the trap of being seen as the “savior,” which is why I suggested “idealized,” as it conveys this feeling of naivety as opposed to the “bad” perspective of “demonisée”.

Other interesting terms that might also fit are: “seen as the villain” for “diabolisée” and “a utopian solutionism” or “under a spell” for “enchantée”. Hope it helps!
Note from asker:
Thank you Ariane, "idealized" could definitely work.
Peer comment(s):

agree philgoddard : Doomed doesn't make sense - I think you may be misunderstanding the English word - but demonized does.
1 hr
Something went wrong...
2 hrs

demonis/zed or romanticis/zed (glamouris/zed)

glamouris/zed, as per the pre-existing Wiki entry, though arguably romanticised better fits a transitional phase.

I wonder whether the ecology subject and/or the asker has a (past) Greenland connection.
Note from asker:
No Greenland connection that I am aware of, why do you ask?
Peer comment(s):

neutral Bourth : Greenland as in Kalaallit Nunaat or as in Alex?
1 day 23 hrs
Something went wrong...
4 hrs

disillusioned or contented

It's about perceptions on the economy, social and political institutions. Opposite possibilities are presented as we can find ourselves dismayed if we're overwhelmed with distrust, fear or discontent, while on the other side we can be happily pleased or even delighted if we find institutions to be in our favour.
Two other opposite terms lead to polarization of how an individual might feel after voting in favour of a politician, a political group or an American president:
disillusionment compared with contentment.
After U.S. presidential elections people could find themselves contented with the systems or unsatisfied and dismayed with a system of health care for example.
Something went wrong...
+2
2 days 11 hrs
French term (edited): ne doit pas être diabolisée ou enchantée

shouldn't be portrayed as either diabolical or magical

IOW neither as "the Devil's work" nor as "a magical solution"

the whole text:

https://presse.ademe.fr/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/AVIS-Tran...
Note from asker:
Thanks, I like "magical solution".
Peer comment(s):

agree Nicole Acher : This is also a good option
20 hrs
Thanks!
agree Emmanuella
1 day 12 hrs
Thanks!
Something went wrong...
Term search
  • All of ProZ.com
  • Term search
  • Jobs
  • Forums
  • Multiple search